Biogenetika pokopala tzv. "Južne Slavene"

[Nadvojvoda Janez Kranjski]

R1b is higher in Croats from northwestern Croatia and probably in Slovenia.

Yeah, about 20%.

There are many variants of R1b. It would be interesting to find out how they are distributed in the areas we discussed:

http://www.worldfamilies.net/Tools/r..._in_europe.htm

[Defensor Fidei]

Probably the large majority of R1b in that areas is Alpine-South German R1b but it is also possible that Baltic-Russian R1b is present in higher frequencies. It is possible that Baltic-Russian R1b has arrived later with slavic migrations. Other types of R1b are for sure minority in this areas. Maybe the part of the so called slavs were Baltic-Russian R1b. I think that R1b in that areas is 70-80 % Alpine-South German and 20-30% Baltic-Russian.

[The Croat]

Pardon my ignorance, but what is R1b an indicator of?

[Nadvojvoda Janez Kranjski]

Originally Posted by The Croat

Pardon my ignorance, but what is R1b an indicator of?

Haplogroup R is a marker which points to the first group of Homo Sapiens that populated Europe. Your question is basically answered here:

http://www.worldfamilies.net/Tools/r..._in_europe.htm

[The Croat]

Originally Posted by Nadvojvoda Janez Kranjski

Haplogroup R is a marker which points to the first group of Homo Sapiens that populated Europe. Your question is basically answered here:

http://www.worldfamilies.net/Tools/r..._in_europe.htm

Cheers.

[Marcus Marulus]

Južni Slaveni su tako i tako uvijek bili samo jezična skupina. Što to uopće znači da ih je "genetika pokopala"?

Među narodima koji govore južnoslavenske jezike tako i tako ima nekoliko rasnih skupina: dinaridi, dunavci, mediteranci...te skupine često se i preklapaju s nacionalnim (etničkim) granicama. "Južnoslavenska rasa" ionako nikada nije postojala, kao ni "južnoslavenska nacija". Mogli bismo dinarce nazvati "južnoslavenskom rasom" (čini mi se da neki rade tu grešku), ali što je onda s onim dunavcima koji govore južnoslavenske jezike?

[Ostrogorski]

не бих обраћао пажњу на те тестове...сваких 15-20 дана се појави неки нови истраживач са својом причом...на крају ће нам генетика "показати" и да ми нисмо Словени него Јапанци,како је кренуло...

[Marcus Marulus]

Etnogeneze i genetska istraživanja naroda tereni su na kojima se lako posklizne u šarlatanizam.

Ima jedna teorija da Dinarci potječu od Kelta.

Onda bih ja bio Kelt, a da to i ne znam?