An arab view on animals rights vs human rights

[Savage]

See the cartoon here...

Source Aljazeera
Spain's parliament is to declare its support for rights to life and freedom for great apes, in what will apparently be the first time any national legislature has recognised such rights for non-humans.

Spanish parliament is to ask the government to approve the Great Ape Project, which would mean recognising that our closest genetic relatives should be part of a "community of equals" with humans, supporters of the resolution said.

Backers of the resolution expect support from the Socialist Party of Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, Spain's prime minister, whose government has legalised gay marriage and reduced the influence of the Catholic Church in education.

"With this, Spain will make itself a world leader in protection of the great apes," said Pedro Pozas, general secretary of the Great Ape Project's Spanish branch.

The resolution was initially due to be voted on on Wednesday but was postponed due to a tight parliamentary agenda, probably until September, said the Green Party parliamentarian who proposed it, Francisco Garrido.

Church concern

However, the proposal prompted criticism and some ridicule at first.

Spanish media quoted the Catholic Archbishop of Pamplona as saying it was ludicrous to grant apes rights not enjoyed by unborn children, in a reference to Spanish abortion laws.

But a spokesman for Archbishop Fernando Sebastian said he had been taken out of context and now supported the resolution.

"We are in favour of defending animals, but people come first," Father Santos Villanueva said.

Philosophers Peter Singer and Paola Cavalieri founded the Great Ape Project in 1993, arguing great apes - chimpanzees, gorillas, orangutans and bonobos - were so close to humans that they deserved rights to life, freedom and not to be tortured.

"When a loved one dies, they grieve for a long time. They can solve complex puzzles that stump most two-year-old humans," said Singer.

Setting a precedent

The Spanish move could set a precedent for greater legal protection for other animals, including elephants, whales and dolphins, said Paul Waldau, director of the Centre for Animals and Public Policy at Tufts University.

"We were born into a society where humans alone are the sole focus and we begin to expand to the non-human great apes," he said.

"It isn't easy for us to see how far that expansion will go, but it's very clear we need to expand beyond humans."

There are only a few hundred apes in Spain, mainly chimpanzees.

However, the resolution would also push the government to help endangered populations in Africa and Asia, added Pozas.

[Milesian]

it was ludicrous to grant apes rights not enjoyed by unborn children, in a reference to Spanish abortion laws.

Touché

[Savage]

The Aljazeera cartoons.

The humour seems to me to be rather flat and plump, there are probably some arab axioms between the lines I do not catch. This is ordered works after a manus, but the drawings are joyous.

Technical, not quite top US standard, rather poor animation, but top score for made by very simple means and no budgets. The "musak" is horrible, but to times illustatrative. Not worse than western propaganda cartoons.

This one, also from Aljazeera is quite universal.

[Batzec]

Originally Posted by Thore Hund

Backers of the resolution expect support from the Socialist Party of Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, Spain's prime minister, whose government has legalised gay marriage and reduced the influence of the Catholic Church in education.
"With this, Spain will make itself a world leader in protection of the great apes," said Pedro Pozas, general secretary of the Great Ape Project's Spanish branch.

For the "Spanish" government everyone and even everything counts, except Spanish decent people.

There are only a few hundred apes in Spain, mainly chimpanzees.

Not, thousands of them. We have a lot of politicians here.

[Llywarch Hen]

Aye, very dull unfunny cartoon.

Didn't New Zealand do this about two years ago?

[Agrippa]

The cartoons are some of the worst I ever saw, horrible. If thats the Arab creativity, bad for them...
Such a major Arab site/station should be able to produce something more valuable.

[Carnyx]

Not very incisive, indeed. I prefer the Iranian cartoons much more.