Non-native fish species - an environmental benefit?

[PointRadix]

Non-Native Fish May Be A Benefit Not A Burden


ScienceDaily (Feb. 28, 2008)

A major study authored by a prominent conservation ecologist from Bournemouth University has found that the majority of non-native fish introduced to freshwater habitats around the world actually do “more good than harm”. Dr Rodolphe Gozlan from Bournemouth's Centre for Conservation Ecology & Environmental Change, believes that too much is made of the “small risks” associated with these introductions. Dr Gozlan’s study - "Introduction of non-native freshwater fish: Is it all bad?" - published in the March issue of the journal 'Fish and Fisheries', reveals that more than half of the 103 non-native freshwater species introduced worldwide were reported to have no adverse ecological impact on their environment.

His analysis of data from the Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) and FishBase found that the risk of ecological impact after the introduction of non-native freshwater fish was less than 10% for a large majority (84%) of the species analysed. The research, funded by the European Commission, foresees an increase in the number of non-native freshwater fish introductions.

Dr Gozlan believes that environmental changes to freshwater ecosystems will inevitably have implications on the distribution of native freshwater fish with a growing reality that we will increasingly depend upon non-native introductions, especially as aquaculture production increases. To support his work, Dr Gozlan cites the introduction of non-native rainbow trout from North America, catfish from Africa, and carp from Asia, to Europe as having numerous benefits. Even non-native species that are considered as detrimental to ecosystems – such as the zebra mussel in the Great Lakes of North America or the Nile perch in Africa’s Lake Victoria – are not evaluated against other environmental pressure (i.e. habitat destruction, overfishing etc.)

Dr Gozlan advises that a more realistic, though controversial, attitude is needed in assessing future risks and calls for a critical debate to be opened on the real threats posed by non-native fish. "This would mean protecting some introductions that present beneficial outcomes for biodiversity alongside a more systematic ban of species or families of fish presenting a higher historical ecological risk,” says Dr Gozlan. “The public perception of risk is something which cannot be ignored by any government or ruling body, but in order to gain public support in the fight for conservation of freshwater fish biodiversity, the message needs to be clear, detailed and educational."

Dr Gozlan also observes that over-assessing the risks attributed to the introduction of non-native freshwater fish has lead to a public perception that all similar introductions are harmful. This perception, he believes, overshadows the measurable benefits to be gained to the ecology and economy by the appropriate introduction of non-native species. “It is the over-assessment of the small risks associated with introducing non-native freshwater fish that has led to the common perception that such introductions pose a threat to biodiversity,” he says.

Source: Non-Native Fish May Be A Benefit Not A Burden

[Susi]

He forgot about the lampreys...

[PointRadix]

After all, this is “funded” research, but to his credit, he was focusing on “useful” (such as edible) fish species more suited to aquaculture, and even suggested a “systematic ban of species or families of fish presenting a higher historical ecological risk”. In terms of Dr Gozlan forgetting lampreys – while the damaging effects of the predatorial ones are well established, some zoologists do not consider lampreys to be “true” fish, because of their vastly different morphology and physiology [Freshwater Fish of Victoria: Lampreys]. Other than that, I think they too, can be eaten.

[Lutiferre]

What are you, fish nationalists?

[Susi]

Lampreys eat the much more delicious and useful fish the Lake trout (amongst others) in the great lakes system. Also, when one swims in this system, sometimes one can come out with a few of the bloody things sticking on one's body.