Do you think the '' Holocaust '' would not had taken place if the Jews has accepted '' Jes

[Sifjar]

Do you think the '' Holocaust '' would not had taken place if the Jews has accepted '' Jesus'' ?

[Martín Zalacaín]

Sorry but this is just surrealistic.

Btw, why is the word "Jesus" in inverted comas?

[Galaico]

What "Holocaust"?

[Sifjar]

Originally Posted by Galaico

What "Holocaust"?

Well the ''Holocaust '' what else, which is historically written and because of it the UN nation was formed in 1948. That '' Holocaust ''

[Galaico]

Originally Posted by Sifjar

Well the ''Holocaust '' what else, which is historically written and because of it the UN nation was formed in 1948. That '' Holocaust ''

Ahhh, the one which was used as an excuse to invade Palestine and to create the Zionist state...

[Sifjar]

Originally Posted by Galaico

Ahhh, the one which was used as an excuse to invade Palestine and to create the Zionist state...

Yes that one, so answer the question

[Susi]

There wouldn't be any Jews if they had accepted Jesus.

[Galaico]

Originally Posted by Sifjar

Yes that one, so answer the question

I can't answer to that, because I don't really know the scale and veracity of such event.

[Der]

Crap poll. What holocaust?

One Third Of The Holocaust (4 hour movie)

Video about NY Times 1933 Headlines "Judea Declares War on Germany"

Ernst Gauss (ed.): Dissecting the Holocaust

[Menydh]

ROFL!

Two things here..

The U.N. is not a reliable source.
Der is not a reliable source.

What's next?

[Kernunnos]

Well, if the Armenians had dropped their christian faith and started considering themselves turks they wouldn't have been mass murdered.

However even if after the Soviet revolution any single soul in soviet territory had wholeheartedly accepted communism many would nonetheless have been killed with the most various accusation, given the puritan and paranoid mindset of communists.

Despite all the above events we have still Turks who proudly declare themselves moslem as well as moslem everywhere in the world.

Communists are so common and unashamedly communist as well.

I don't see why we should mind this Holothing that much give the above examples: that genocide wasn't a real nationalist act, whatever its dimensions could be: so it doesn't really touch us since we carry no link to the ideology of the perpetrators.

True or false, the so called Holocaust wasn't an offer to any God, as the use of world holocaust not so subtly implies: it is the word that was given to it to make it a special act with religious undertones.

An act of the new civil religion we all have to follow willing or not, an that puts the Jews in a superior moral position with respect to anybody.

It was just a plain genocide, and it stands no higher and no lower than any other genocide of that century, carrying no special character to make the population that suffered it a special one.

There is no special merit in being a victim, no higher moral status in the after.

[Carnyx]

Is it too much asked to have at least a day free of reference to ze Holocaust?

[Errigal]

Originally Posted by Carnyx

Is it too much asked to have at least a day free of reference to ze Holocaust?

I know what you mean, but if it has to be talked about I think Breha covered the topic quite well.

As for the question "Do you think the Holocaust would have taken place if the Jews had accepted Jesus?". Well that reminds me of Putin's Grandparent Paradox:

"There is a proverb that says if a grandmother had certain reproductive organs, she would have been a grandfather. Politics does not accept subjunctive mood."

source

Maybe someone should test results of a mass conversion to Christianity by Jews before WW2 in some kind of social networking game like Simcity or maybe Age of Empires?

[Sifjar]

Originally Posted by Mynydd

ROFL!



The U.N. is not a reliable source.

Define what you consider as reliable source ? You just can't say it without defining it, Even a child could do that, so what you consider as reliable source and motivate why ''UN'' is not a reliable source? Im waiting for you answer .

[Arthur Gordon Pym]

The title of this thread is totally unserious. It is mixing two things that have absolutely nothing to do with each other.

[Sifjar]

Originally Posted by Plethon

The title of this thread is totally unserious. It is mixing two things that have absolutely nothing to do with each other.

Yes it does, it based on your perspectives how you approach problems solving, I'm sure you have done it a-lot at school ? Everything has a history nothing pops out from nothing