Thread: Meta-ethnicity?
View Single Post
  #28 (permalink)     Quote this post in a PM
Old Tuesday, January 15th, 2008
Weltschmerz's Avatar
Weltschmerz Weltschmerz is offline
Senior Moderator
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Age: 33
Posts: 2,031
Blog Entries: 2
Weltschmerz 's wisdom is legendary.Weltschmerz 's wisdom is legendary.Weltschmerz 's wisdom is legendary.Weltschmerz 's wisdom is legendary.Weltschmerz 's wisdom is legendary.Weltschmerz 's wisdom is legendary.Weltschmerz 's wisdom is legendary.Weltschmerz 's wisdom is legendary.Weltschmerz 's wisdom is legendary.Weltschmerz 's wisdom is legendary.Weltschmerz 's wisdom is legendary.
Default Re: Meta-ethnicity?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Faustas View Post
Assuming that the term denotes only linguistics and nothing else does not make any individual speaking a Germanic language Germanic, but any individual who is a member of a nation of Germanic-speakers. Belonging to a meta-ethnicity requires belonging to an ethnicity that falls under that particular meta-ethnic umbrella. Thus the black girl in your picture, no matter what, is not Germanic, even if the term is only linguistic.
I would say that Germanic is not only a linguistic concept, but primarily ethnic, while an important part of shared Germanic heritage is linguistic. The linguistic meaning of Germanic is contained in the ethnic meaning.
__________________
Den västerländska traditionen kan man vara trogen bara genom att ifrågasätta den med förnuftet som måttstock.

Svante Nordin, Det pessimistiska förnuftet



Wir haben eine ältere Offenbarung als jede geschriebene, die Natur.

Friedrich Schelling, Über das Wesen der menschlichen Freiheit



The French were always there when they needed us.

American proverb
Reply With Quote