Quote:
Originally Posted by Mynydd
I'm left wondering.
|
Perhaps you are not familiar with what I was describing.
Quote:
|
But the uncertainty associated with the Cimbri is exactly a good reason to refer to "North Germanic" tribes as "Scandinavian tribes", and "Germanic paganism" as "Scandinavian paganism", because thats where it originates - same with Viking culture.
|
Wikipedia has a section that sums it up pretty effectively:
Cimbri - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
There is uncertainty about whether the Cimbri were Celtic or Germanic; linguistic uncertainty. And there is reason to believe both things.
That is why I suggested we refer to tribes in the Scandinavian peninsula as
Scandinavian tribes rather than North
Germanic tribes, due to the associated uncertainty about the Cimbri Celtic-Germanic question. There I answered your question:
Quote:
|
Why would you prefer to say Scandinavian than Northern Germanic?
|
Whats more, "Germanic" paganism should be referred to as "Nordic" or "Scandinavian" paganism, since thats where it originates, and not anywhere else in the Germanic areas.