View Single Post
  #8 (permalink)     Quote this post in a PM
Old Sunday, August 26th, 2007
Youenn's Avatar
Youenn Youenn está offline
Veteran Member
 
Last Online: Monday, November 17th, 2008 02:59
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Brest
Age: 23
Posts: 561
Youenn is considered wise by the elders.Youenn is considered wise by the elders.Youenn is considered wise by the elders.Youenn is considered wise by the elders.Youenn is considered wise by the elders.Youenn is considered wise by the elders.Youenn is considered wise by the elders.
Default Re: The Decline & Splender of Nationalism

Quote:
Originally Posted by Theobald View Post
Do you and Sunic make any distinction between French and French Jacobines ?
Indeed. Kings of France already wanted to colonize other non-French areas. Jacobins didn't invent the imperialism in France.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Theobald View Post
Mass massacres happened during the conquest of Franche-Comté, like mass massacres happened everywhere in Europe during about every war, conquest and invasion.
I haven't heard of mass murders like in Franche-Comté during the German reunification; and when the Alsace was occupied by Germany there weren't concentration camps like the camp "Margueritte".

Quote:
Originally Posted by Theobald View Post
Perhaps, but you don't start an armed insurrection to support a political leader that was deposed if this very political leader has oppressed you and tried to destroy your ethnic group. Do you see Iraqi Kurds fighting for Saddam ?
We can not say that during the monarchy there was an ethnocide policy, it was more to reduce a bit the local liberties. Louis XVI wasn't Francois Ier or Louis XIV, and between Louis XVI and republicans, there is a world apart. This king was may be the most "liberal" for the local liberties.
Anyway, it's highly impossible to compare him with Saddam who has created a state with french republicans and communists influence, laic and anti-ethnic. It's for this reason that french stato-nationalist like him I suppose.
Reply With Quote